How helicopter rescues in Nepal are revolutionising - and complicating - mountain adventures
Helicopter rescues in Nepal’s Himalayas are saving lives, but a surge in evacuations has led to insurance fraud, increased premiums, and ethical concerns. As Ed Douglas reports, this new rescue industry may impact your next trekking adventure.
Additional reporting by Richard Bull in Kathmandu
Rescue in the Himalaya is changing. The extraordinary escape of three climbers stricken with frostbite and altitude sickness at almost 7,000m on Annapurna in 2010 is a great example. In the past, they would probably have not survived, yet a powerful Ecureuil B3 helicopter plucked the three men to safety in the nick of time. The Swiss team – pilot Daniel Aufdenblatten and rescuer Richard Lehner from Air Zermatt – were in Nepal to train local helicopter crews in rescue techniques when they got the call. “Until then,” Aufdenblatten said, “helicopter rescues at those altitudes had been regarded as impossible.”
The rise of Nepal’s helicopter industry
Nepal’s civil aviation industry has flourished since the end of its civil war in 2006. With tourism numbers doubling, especially on Everest, the demand for medical evacuations has risen dramatically. Every year, over 100,000 trekkers visit Nepal, and more of them are requiring helicopter rescues. This sounds like a good thing — but there’s a catch.
Weak regulation and easy access to insurance money have turned rescues into a lucrative business. Middlemen and agents, eager for commissions, have created a competitive industry, playing helicopter operators against one another. Even trekking guides and agencies are getting in on the act.
David Hamilton, an experienced guide for Jagged Globe, highlighted the growing problem early on: “Imagine you’re a local guide leading a trek of six people for a fairly low-budget outfit. The agent will only be making $500 out of the whole deal. You’ve got someone who’s going a bit slow and it’s a pain waiting for them, you tell them they’ve got altitude sickness, you call in a helicopter and your company gets ten or 15% of what, $10,000? In a couple of years, when the insurance companies start looking at the books, there’s going to be a massive price hike.”
The cost to insurance
The impact on insurance is now being felt. Premiums for travel insurance to Nepal, particularly for trekking, have soared. While it’s great to have better emergency coverage, rising expenses mean higher premiums.
The real question is whether the increased premiums are covering legitimate rescues or funding fraudulent activity. According to a helicopter pilot based in Nepal, kickbacks, haggling, and inflated costs are rampant. “A client getting sick is good for the trekking companies,” the pilot said. “A client may be paying $1,500 for a trek in the Everest region, but if he gets sick the [trekking] company might make $2,000 or $3,000 out of it from the rescue helicopter.”
How fraud is impacting trekkers and insurance companies
Trekkers rarely carry the phone numbers of local helicopter operators. Instead, they depend on their guides to make the call. Some guides work with charter companies or directly with helicopter operators, negotiating the best price — and commission — for the rescue.
Not only does the charter company haggle over the price, according to the pilot they also request a fake bill. “If you don’t agree then you don’t get the business. Even if we fly only two hours, they ask for a bill for five hours. Nowadays they don’t even ask for the bill, they give their own bill.”
Helicopter companies in Nepal face high operating costs, including insurance rates of 15% of the helicopter’s value per year, which can amount to $375,000. Meanwhile, middlemen and agents are reaping profits without any significant investment.
What can be done to curb the fraud?
Insurance companies can take steps to prevent inflated rescue costs. The pilot suggests asking for detailed flight logs, which are difficult to fake. “There are only certain companies here making rescue flights. You can ask which company made the flight? How many hours did it fl y? Ask for the check log. We write everything down. I can’t fake the check log. If I write ten hours instead of two hours, then the helicopter has to be serviced eight hours earlier.”
The pilot estimated that around 1,500 tourist emergency flights are conducted each year, primarily for trekkers. That’s millions of dollars of commission up for grabs, so it’s hardly surprising that the growth of Nepal’s private helicopter sector has attracted middlemen looking for a slice.
So much for sharp practice, what about outright fraud? Are all those ill people getting a ride home really sick? “I cannot say by looking at their faces,” the pilot says. “Half look quite fit but I cannot decide. I just fly the helicopter – I’m not a doctor. The agents will have called an ambulance, they take them to CIWEC (the reputable and longstanding travel medicine centre near the British embassy) or an international clinic, they go there and get certified as sick.” But, he says, the evacuation of healthy people happens: “A lot.”
There seem to be at least five categories of fraudulent use of insurance policies to profit from helicopter rescues: unnecessary evacuations, fast rides down, overcharging rescues, charging twice for the same rescue and deliberately scheduling ‘rescue’ flights into trekking itineraries. Researching this article, we found direct evidence for all of them.
Unnecessary evacuations and fraudulent claims
According to Prakash Adhikari, chief executive of the Himalayan Rescue Association (HRA), helicopters have complicated the work of organisations like the HRA, which operates health posts along popular trekking routes. In the 2012 autumn season, HRA authorised only 15 helicopter evacuations, mostly for serious altitude-related conditions like HAPE (high-altitude pulmonary edema) and HACE (high-altitude cerebral edema). Yet, many trekking guides bypass these health posts, fearing the HRA won’t authorise an evacuation that could result in a large commission.
One paramedic shared a story of a trekker feigning illness to secure a helicopter evacuation. Others report that some patients evacuated by helicopter were perfectly healthy. According to a doctor in Kathmandu, 20% of those evacuated didn’t need a helicopter at all.
How to protect yourself from fraud on your next trek
Helicopter rescues have become an essential part of high-altitude trekking in Nepal, but they come with risks — including higher insurance premiums and the possibility of fraud. To avoid falling victim, choose a reputable trekking company, prepare thoroughly, and familiarise yourself with proper acclimatisation techniques.
The bottom line? While helicopter rescues offer a vital safety net, the increase in fraudulent claims could put your health and holiday at risk — and cost you more in insurance premiums.
The scams
1 - Unnecessary Evacuation of someone who would recover
Inexperienced trekkers can be persuaded by lodge owners or trekking guides that they need treatment in Kathmandu, when descent or analgesics would suffice. That treatment can often be hugely profitable: a straightforward check-up following evacuation can cost up to $800 and two or three days in hospital $5,000. At least one helicopter-charter company now has its own medical facility where patients are delivered after being evacuated – a new twist on unscrupulous cab drivers taking you to his ‘brother’s’ hotel.
2 - Overcharging for the rescue
This can work in other ways. Lodge owners calling in a chopper for a stricken guest have been known to ask for goods to be flown in on the incoming flight, and tourists in the area may find themselves being offered a cash-in-hand ride back to Kathmandu.
3 - Charging twice for the same rescue
An organiser in the Manaslu region arranged a helicopter evacuation for two clients – from different countries – suffering from altitude sickness. He learned later that both insurance companies had been billed for the entire $5,000 cost of the charter, totalling $10,000. The profit on the deal would have been around $7,000.
4 - Trekkers or climbers looking for a fast ride down following an expedition
With the right contacts, it’s not difficult to get what looks like bona fide documentation saying that a rescue was medically justified and the insurance company picks up the bill. This isn’t confined to Nepalese trek leaders
5 - Deliberate scheduling of a ‘rescue’ flight in a trekker’s itinerary to save them time
This was offered without prompting to a Dutch group planning a complex itinerary in the Kangchenjunga area. When they decided to include two friends for part of it, they received an email from their agent:
“In the beginning they have to pay helicopter cost in Nepal, when they completed there [sic] trekking and arrive in Kathmandu I will make the doctor report saying that we need to rescue the people from Ghunsa because they are ill and the aviation people will too make the certificate saying that we are rescuing these people.”
The plan, the agent says, will be ‘a good solution for them,’ and to reassure their prospective clients, the agent goes on to say: ‘I started Nepal tourism business since 1990 most of the time I did the same like this and there was no problem at all till now.’
Climb and protect: BMC specialist travel insurance covers your adventures and funds conservation
With every policy, profits are reinvested into the BMC’s vital work on behalf of climbers, hill walkers and mountaineers.
Related Content
Rock Destinations
British climbing legend Steve McClure highlights his top five winter destinations for warm rock.
Rock Climbing Articles
Our specialist BMC Travel Insurance has got you covered as you head off abroad in the hunt for sunny climbs.
Rock Destinations
Dreaming of big numbers this year? We reveal six sizzling holiday rock destinations that will send your grade through the roof. Whether your sight is on 6b or you're aching for 8a, here are Steve McClure's top picks.
Rock Destinations
Think that you can't climb towers like these? Think again. Clip into our top ten via ferratas and reach heights that normal walks just can't reach.
Rock Destinations
Planning an adventure? Remember to pack BMC Travel Insurance. We’ve got your back: from bouldering in France to trekking in India, sport climbing in Kalymnos to new routes in the Himalaya. Here are five reasons why BMC Travel Insurance is built for the mountains.
Mountaineering Destinations
Want to know everything you need to know about how to climb the Breithorn - one of the classic "4,000ers". Mountain Guide Andy Perkins offers his insider tips.
Rock Destinations
Travel insurance may add to the costs of a holiday. However, travelling with the right policy in place gives you the confidence to travel and enjoy your adventurous activities without worry. If you’ve recently had a quote for BMC Travel Insurance and wondered why it seems to be unexpectedly expensive, read on for some information that might be helpful.
Mountaineering Destinations
Now is the prime time to plan your winter adventures. To help you explore the British mountains over winter, we have chosen six stunning winter ridges to guarantee a grand day out.
Mountaineering Destinations
The Matterhorn is surely the world’s most iconic peak. Its commanding, isolated position at the head of the valley is unique in the Alps and its claim to being one of the world’s most beautiful mountains is justified. Mountain Guide Tim Blakemore offers his top tips on reaching its summit successfully.
Mountaineering Destinations
We asked five experienced climbers for their top pick of Europe's alpine routes to get you inspired...
Hillwalking Skills
How to choose an ice axe for your next winter adventure
Rock Climbing Gear
Everything you need to know about the various types of rope for climbing and mountaineering can be found in our handy, free guide.
Hillwalking Skills
In this guide, we share tips to help you navigate your way back to safety in the event of a whiteout.
Rock Destinations
Have you ticked this list? Five British IFMGA mountain guides pick their absolute favourite long rock routes in the Italian Dolomites, the Aravis range close to Chamonix, and from the ‘Grats’ near Andermatt to the Monts Rouges du Triolet; there’s something for everyone to go at from 5c to 7a. If in any doubt of your skills and experience, you know the score: hire a guide.
Mountaineering Destinations
Five of Chamonix's leading ski guides tell us their favourite beginner ski tours in and around Chamonix.
Rock Climbing Articles
Test your knowledge and see if you can name these 10 famous British female mountaineers and climbers, from pantaloon-clad pioneers of the alps, to contemporary crushers.
Mountaineering Destinations
This route of great tradition and history has foiled many a keen adventurer, so what does it take to unlock the aura of mystery surrounding Tower Ridge? Fortunately we have film maker and mountaineer Steve Ashworth on hand to explain it all for us.
Hillwalking Skills
When should you use crampons? Our guide explains the 'when', 'where' and 'how' of deploying your spiky winter gear.
Mountaineering Destinations
What's the best 4,000m peak in the Alps for beginners? We asked five British Mountain Guides who are based in the Alps this question - Tim Blakemore, Jon Bracey, Matt Helliker, Andy Perkins and Tania Noakes. All of them picked a peak in Switzerland - testament to the concentration of excellent peaks of that altitude there.
Mountaineering Destinations
Here are some facts, figures and background information on the world's highest mountain.
Rock Destinations
Thought sport climbing was all about tiny holds on short routes? Think again. Here we've got five top European venues to recommend you:
Mountaineering Destinations
Get the inside knowledge: Chamonix-based Mountain Guides Will Sim and Stuart MacDonald offer the wealth of their experience for those thinking of ticking the highest point in Western Europe.
Hill Walking Articles
Having a duvet day or a quiet night in? We've got you covered. There's nothing better than a day in the hills - but we think planning a day in the hills comes in pretty close second. If you're looking for inspiration for your next on-foot adventure, check out our lineup of ten of the best mountaineering, hiking and hillwalking films from the BMC TV YouTube channel.
Mountaineering Learn Gear
Do you carry a first aid kit in the mountains? We take a look at the essentials for any mountaineering first aid kit and how to use them.
Mountaineering Destinations
Mountains have always meant more to humanity than just lumps of rock. We take a look at five summits with mysterious, magical or mythological significance.
Rock Destinations
Planning a winter sport-climbing escape? Leave the crowds and polish behind with these five best-kept mid-grade Spanish sport secrets. Dos cervezas por favor.
Mountaineering Destinations
If you’re looking for an unforgettable, high altitude trekking holiday this year we’ve got some great ideas for you here in Nepal, Bhutan, Pakistan and India from climbing mountaineering expedition operator Jagged Globe.
Here are our top picks for Deep Water Soloing locations in Europe.
Mountaineering Articles
Where are you currently getting your mountain inspiration from? Are the walls in your house lined with photos and paintings of stunning peaks? Your social media feeds endlessly presenting you with trails and skylines to add to the list of high places to explore? We're here to add to that by giving you five more films to keep your inspiration levels up. Enjoy the watch.
Mountaineering Articles
Looking at protecting your finances in the event of illness can be tough for anybody, but for a climber it can be doubly daunting. Not only have you to consider which protection you require but you also have to find a company which will actually cover you properly.
Organisation
The BMC have partnered with HotelPlanner, a leading travel technology platform and hotel booking search engine. The partnership includes a revenue share on member hotel bookings as their Official Accommodation Provider for all BMC events. This partnership means that all BMC members will receive discounted accommodation via the HotelPlanner platform.
Mountaineering Learn Skills
Dreaming of summit glory? You're in luck: there are still many unclimbed mountains out there. All that stands between you and a victorious summit pose is some research...
Rock Destinations
Leo Houlding marked his 40th birthday by introducing the next generation of his family to the kind of adventures that he has become renowned for. The Houlding family spent four days climbing Piz Badile, with his children becoming two of the youngest climbers to stand on the summit.
Mountaineering News
Sarah Stirling tracks down mountaineer Paul Ramsden to find out his opinions on his latest award-winning route, sponsored climbers and the media spotlight.